If you’ve searched for a local service recently, you’ve probably noticed something has changed.
The Google results page is no longer just local packs or blue links.
Today, service-based searches are dominated by local service ads (LSAs), paid search ads, and AI overviews, with traditional local SEO pushed further down the page.
This has left many business owners asking:
Is local SEO still worth it?
Are local service ads replacing SEO?
Where should my marketing budget go?
Let’s break it down properly.
Key Notes
Local Service Ads dominate top SERP positions and operate on a pay-per-lead model for services.
LSAs and Google Business Profiles are separate systems with independent verification, categories, and targeting controls.
Weak GBP optimization increases LSA costs and lowers visibility and lead quality.
Multi-channel visibility across SEO, LSAs, and AI search drives the strongest local lead flow.
What Is a Local Service Ad?
Local Service Ads (LSAs) are Google’s pay-per-lead ad format designed specifically for service-based businesses.
They appear above everything else on the search results page and visually resemble the Local Pack – but they’re paid placements.
Key Characteristics of Local Service Ads:
Appear at the very top of the SERP
Show business name, reviews, service area, and trust badges
Charge per lead (call or message), not per click
Are closely linked to your Google Business Profile
In simple terms:
LSAs are Google’s paid version of local visibility.
They don’t replace Local SEO – they sit on top of it.

How Local Service Ads Are Impacting Local SEO
The biggest impact isn’t rankings – it’s call volume.
As LSAs take up more SERP real estate, we’re seeing:
Fewer calls coming directly from Google Business Profiles
Users clicking or calling LSAs before ever reaching the Local Pack
Increased competition for attention above organic results
This doesn’t mean Local SEO is “dying”.
It means the funnel has shifted.
Local SEO is no longer the first thing users see. But it’s still foundational.
Should You Stop Doing Local SEO?
Short answer: absolutely not.
Here’s the critical part most people miss:
Your Google Business Profile is still foundational to Local Service Ads – but it does not directly control everything inside LSAs.
Local Service Ads and Google Business Profiles are two separate systems that communicate, not a single shared setup.
Here’s How That Relationship Actually Works:
Business legitimacy for LSAs comes from a separate verification process (Google Guaranteed / Google Screened), including background checks, license checks, and insurance verification – not just GBP verification.
Reviews and ratings are the strongest shared signal. When linked, GBP reviews appear on LSAs and heavily influence trust and performance.
Categories and services are not pulled from GBP. LSAs use their own supported industries and “job types,” which must be manually selected inside the LSA dashboard.
Service areas are also managed independently. While your GBP address is used as a starting reference, LSA targeting is defined separately by zip code or radius.
So while a strong, well-optimized GBP is essential, LSAs have their own controls, eligibility rules, and optimization levers.
If Your GBP Is Weak, Incomplete, or Poorly Managed:
Your LSAs will underperform
Your cost per lead will increase
Your visibility and trust will suffer
Think of it like this:
Local SEO = the foundation
LSAs = the paid accelerator
You don’t run LSAs instead of Local SEO.
You run them because your Local SEO is strong.

Why Local Service Ads Are Now Essential
The modern service-based SERP looks like this:
Local Service Ads (Top 3 + “View more”)
Traditional Search Ads
AI Overview
Local Pack (sometimes with sponsored results)
Organic listings (often Reddit, forums, aggregators)
This means:
Even #1 in the Local Pack doesn’t guarantee visibility
Organic blue links are now late-stage results
Paid and AI-driven placements dominate first impressions
If you’re not visible across multiple layers of the SERP, you’re losing market share – even if your SEO is “good”.

How to Set a Local Service Ads Budget (The Smart Way)
Google actually gives you a built-in estimator.
Here’s the simple process:
Go to:
https://business.google.com/ca-en/ad-solutions/local-service-ads/Scroll to the budget estimation section
Enter:
Your postal code
Your industry
Desired number of leads per month
You’ll get:
Confirmation of whether your service is eligible
An estimated monthly budget range
Important:
The estimate is a guideline – not a guarantee.
Actual costs depend on:
Competition
Reviews
Responsiveness
Profile and account optimisation
Where SEO Still Wins (And Always Will)
Local SEO is no longer just about:
Ranking a homepage
Adding keywords to service pages
Publishing generic blog posts
The future is search experience optimization.
This includes:
Traditional SEO
Local SEO
AEO / GEO (AI & Generative Engine Optimisation)
Google’s AI Overviews make one thing clear:
Visibility now depends on how consistently and clearly your brand is understood across the web – not just on your website.
SEO, AEO, GEO – Call It What You Want, But It Matters
Optimizing only for keyword rankings is outdated.
Modern optimization means:
Covering full query fanouts (not just one keyword)
Structuring content for AI understanding
Consistent brand mentions across platforms
Semantic relevance, not keyword stuffing
Authority signals beyond your own site
That Includes:
Your website
Google Business Profile
Facebook
Reddit
Directories
Industry platforms
AI systems don’t just rank pages – they evaluate brands.
The Real Play: Multi-Channel Local Visibility
The businesses winning today aren’t choosing between:
Local SEO or
Local Service Ads
They’re combining:
Strong GBP optimization
Well-structured Local SEO
LSAs with controlled budgets
Brand presence across multiple platforms
Content built for humans and AI systems
Marketing has changed.
Single-channel strategies no longer work.

Final Thoughts
Local Service Ads are not the end of Local SEO – they’re the next layer on top of it.
If you:
Ignore LSAs → you lose top-of-page visibility
Ignore Local SEO → your LSAs underperform
Ignore AI-driven search → your brand fades from future results
The businesses that win are the ones that adapt early and build visibility everywhere users – and AI systems – are looking.
If your current setup isn’t built like this, you’re leaving revenue on the table. Book your free discovery call – we’ve done it successfully for contractors and local businesses nationwide.




